Melissa R. McCartney PhD

Melissa McCartney

Melissa R. McCartney
PhD

Associate Professor

Department of Pharmacology and Toxicology

Jacobs School of Medicine & Biomedical Sciences


Specialty/Research Focus

Biomedical Education

Contact Information
955 Main Street
3213
Buffalo, New York 14203
Phone: 716-881-8003
mrm10@buffalo.edu



Professional Summary:

My research lab is motivated by my own experiences with non-academic jobs and what these experiences taught me about developing a robust and diverse scientific workforce that expands outside of academia. The demand for biomedical scientists is expected to increase over the next decade and retention of all future biomedical scientists within the STEM workforce is critical, we cannot afford to lose students at graduation. Therefore, my lab focuses on cultivating and retaining the future biomedical/STEM workforce.

We cultivate the future STEM workforce by:

1. Understanding career development factors of biology and biomedical science majors. The most cited theoretical framework underlying career development is Social Cognitive Career Theory (SCCT), which outlines students’ career development processes using three central factors: 1) student career goals and the career development strategies employed to reach these goals, 2) career self-efficacy, and 3) career outcome expectations. Our lab collects data on these SCCT factors on an annual basis to better understand where students are on their career development trajectories. We use complex statistics to examine trends in student data across SCCT factors and evaluate how students engage with these factors over time.

2. Enabling students to realize their scientific skills and identities en route to a STEM career. Almost half of undergraduates in a STEM major choose to pursue different careers than originally intended, and many students continue to deliberate possible careers long after completing their undergraduate education. We should not assume that students are progressing toward intended STEM careers simply because they have persisted in STEM. Retaining STEM graduates in the workforce starts with teaching them how to navigate STEM career paths. We have developed and implemented career development workshops and courses specific to biology and biomedical science majors, and we have shown that participation in these offerings increases students’ science and biology identities. We continue this line of research by qualitatively investigating the mechanisms underlying these identity shifts and examining longitudinal data.

3. Examining the sense of belonging among undergraduate STEM majors at the departmental level. A sense of belonging is positively associated with academic achievement and retention, while science identity is positively associated with STEM career choice and degree persistence. We have previously developed and validated a sense of belonging questionnaire focused at the departmental level to measure whether students feel connected to their department. Because the department is where students interact with a wide range of faculty and staff, departments have numerous opportunities to foster a strong sense of belonging. We continue to expand this line of research by developing related assessments on the climate and culture of undergraduate departments. Given that the relationship between a sense of belonging and academic climate and culture is not well understood at any academic level, our research expands the scope of existing knowledge in this area. Additionally, by incorporating the student voice into academic climate change efforts, our work provides students with the agency and empowerment necessary to help their departments become more inclusive.


We retain the future STEM workforce by:

1. Examining the master's experience (who engages in a master's program and why?): Biomedical and health sciences master’s programs are increasingly used by premedical students as transitional pathways to medical school admissions, often as part of a structured gap year. Despite their growing prevalence, little is known about how these programs influence students’ career readiness and science identity. Our research comprehensively evaluates the experiences of students engaging in a master’s program as a pathway to medical school admittance through the lens of career development and science identity.

2. Examining the gap year phenomenon (who engages in a gap year and why?): Federal funding agencies rarely support research on the career trajectories of biology and biomedical science graduates in the time between degree completion and enrollment in graduate or post-baccalaureate programs. Nevertheless, "gap years," a crucial period for career development, have become increasingly common among these graduates. Little is known about why students choose to take a gap year(s), what kind of career development occurs during these years, and whether these graduates are ultimately retained in the STEM workforce. We use a mixed-methods approach to investigate student gap year experiences.

3. Examining the lab-switching phenomenon (who switches labs and why?): Research on graduate program attrition has predominantly focused on students who depart from their PhD programs entirely. However, a type of attrition that remains understudied is the phenomenon of doctoral students switching labs. We view switching labs as a form of attrition that should be studied and prevented to: 1) promote positive student outcomes (e.g., timely completion of the degree) and 2) protect the significant financial investments made when matriculating PhD students into programs. We examine the attrition occurring through lab switching by starting at the foundation: evaluating current trends and collecting qualitative data on student experiences.

Education and Training:

  • Fellowship, Science and Technology Policy Fellow, The National Academies (2009)
  • Fellowship, Postdoctoral Fellow, The Children's Hospital of Philadelphia (2008)
  • PhD, Neuroscience, The George Washington University (2006)
  • BS, Biochemistry, Binghamton University (SUNY) (2000)

Employment:

  • Associate Dean of Undergraduate Education, Pharmacology and Toxicology, Jacobs School of Medicine and Biomedical Sciences (2026-present)
  • Assistant Professor, Biological Sciences, Florida International University (2017–2023)
  • Program Manager, American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) (2015–2016)
  • Associate Editor, Science (2009–2014)

Awards and Honors:

  • Top Scholar Award (2023)
  • Research Award (2023)
  • Service Award (2020)
  • Outreach Award (2019)

Research Expertise:

  • career development, science identity, sense of belonging, assessment design, quantitative methods, qualitative methods, mixed-methods

Journal Articles:

See all (19 more)

Professional Memberships:

  • Graduate Career Consortium (GCC) (2022–present)
  • Society for the Advancement of Biology Education Research (SABER) (2017–present)
  • National Science Teachers Association (NSTA) (2015–present)
  • National Association of Biology Teachers (NABT) (2015–present)
  • American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) (2009–present)
  • Association of Women in Science (AWIS) (2007–present)
  • Society for Neuroscience (SfN) (2002–present)

Presentations:

  • "Biology Beyond Medicine: Guiding Pre-Med Students Towards Fulfilling Careers in Healthcare and Science." University at Buffalo Neuroscience Research Day (2025)
  • "Biology Beyond Medicine: Guiding Pre-Med Students Toward Fulfilling Careers in Biomedical Science." Syracuse University Invited Speaker (2025)
  • "Biology Beyond Medicine: Guiding Pre-Med Students Towards Fulfilling Careers in Healthcare and Science." Rochester Academy of Science (2025)
  • "Stable in Goals, Adaptable in Strategies: A Sequential-Exploratory Approach to Developing an Assessment for Undergraduate Biology and Biomedical Science Students Career Goals and Supporting Career Strategies." Society for Advancement of Chicanos/Hispanics & Native Americans in Science (SACNAS) (2025)
  • "A Cross-Disciplinary Study of Climate and Culture in Science Departments." Society to Advance Biology Education Research (SABER) National Meeting (2025)
  • "Advising undergraduate biology students with pre-med career goals." Society to Advance Biology Education Research Meeting (SABER) (2025)
  • "Investigating the effect of participating in research experiences on biology undergraduates’ career readiness." Society for the Advancement of Biology Education Research (SABER) National Meeting, (2025)
  • "Stable Goals, Adaptable Strategies: A Sequential-Exploratory Approach to Developing an Assessment for Undergraduate Biology and Biomedical Science Students Career Goals and Supporting Career Strategies." Society to Advance Biology Education Research Meeting (SABER) (2025)
  • "Text vs. Visuals: Rethinking Survey Design for Inclusivity in Science Education." Society to Advance Biology Education Research Meeting (SABER) (2025)
  • "What Happens When Undergraduate Biology Students Meet with Professional Scientists to Discuss Research? An Exploratory Investigation into Scientific Discourse, Motivation, and Sense of Belonging." Science Communication Education Research Network (SCERN) Meeting (2025)
  • "Assessing Career Readiness and Science Identity of Biological and Health Sciences Master’s Students." Society for the Advancement of Biology Education Research (SABER) (2025)
  • "Biology Beyond Medicine: Guiding Pre-Med Students Toward Fulfilling Careers in Healthcare and Science." Society for the Advancement of Biology Education Research (SABER) (2025)
  • "Careers+, a week-long boot camp for undergraduate career development." Florida International University hosted the workshop (2025)
  • "Developing, and measuring, science identity in undergraduate STEM students." Tufts University Seminar Series (2025)
  • "Faculty vs. Student Perspectives: A Cross-Disciplinary Study of Climate and Culture in Science Departments." Society for the Advancement of Biology Education Research (SABER) (2025)
  • "From Experience to Advice: What PhD Students Want Future Trainees to Know About Mentor Selection." Society for the Advancement of Biology Education Research (SABER) (2025)
  • "Stable in Goals, Adaptable in Strategies: A Sequential-Exploratory Approach to Developing an Assessment for Undergraduate Biology and Biomedical Science Students Career Goals and Supporting Career Strategies." Society for the Advancement of Biology Education Research (SABER) (2025)
  • "Text vs. Visuals: Rethinking Questionnaire Design for Inclusivity in Science Education." Society for the Advancement of Biology Education Research (SABER) (2025)
  • "Undergraduate biology majors career readiness: what does it look like and when is it happening." Society for the Advancement of Biology Education Research (SABER) (2025)
  • "Assessing perspectives on departmental climate, culture, and sense of belonging in science." AAAS Emerging Researchers Conference (2025)
  • "Exploring High School Biology Teachers Engagement with Primary Scientific Literature." The Denman Undergraduate Research Forum at The Ohio State University. (2025)
  • "Power, Policy, and Practice, a Jacobs School Teach-in. Funding the Future: Science policy at the crossroads," JSMBS event (2025)
  • "Advancing more students from STEM degree to STEM workforce: is targeted career development the key?" University at Buffalo Institute for Learning Sciences Speaker Series (2025)
  • "Spring Forward!, a week-long boot camp for undergraduate career development." Florida International University hosted the workshop (2025)
  • "Reinforcing Belonging and Scientific Identity in Predoctoral Trainees" Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) Biomedical Research Training Conference Hosted by the Group on Research, Education, and Training (GREAT) (2024)
  • "Assessing Undergraduate Perspectives on Climate, Culture, and Sense of Belonging in Science Departments." Society to Advance Biology Education Research Meeting (SABER) (2024)
  • "Development and evaluation of CURE+, a research internship course in virus bioinformatics." Society to Advance Biology Education Research Meeting (SABER) (2024)
  • "Investigating Career and Research Experience Access Through Evidence (iCREATE) at a Hispanic-Serving Institute." Society to Advance Biology Education Research Meeting (SABER) (2024)
  • "Moving more students from STEM degree to STEM workforce: is targeted career development the key? ," Society to Advance Biology Education Research Meeting (SABER) (2024)
  • "Undergraduate Life Science Professors’ Perception of the Vision and Change Core Content and Competencies for Preparing Students for Science Careers." Society to Advance Biology Education Research Meeting (SABER) (2024)
  • "Understanding biology students’ undergraduate mentoring experiences at a Hispanic-Serving Institution." Society to Advance Biology Education Research Meeting (SABER) (2024)
  • "Career Development for Biologists" Harvard University School of Forestry Summer REU program (2024)
  • "How to be a researcher: job skills and identity." University at Buffalo Department of Biological Sciences Summer REU program (2024)
  • "Resume workshop: learning to present your best self" University at Buffalo Department of Biological Sciences Summer REU program (2024)
  • "Who are your advocates? Strategies for reference letters." University at Buffalo Department of Biological Sciences Summer REU program (2024)
  • "Assessing Undergraduate Perspectives on Climate, Culture, and Sense of Belonging in Science Departments." Society to Advance Biology Education Research Meeting (SABER) East (2024)
  • "Development and evaluation of CURE+, a bioinformatics-driven biomedical research internship course." FIU Institute for Biomedical Sciences spring conference (2024)
  • "Moving more students from STEM degree to STEM workforce: is targeted career development the key?" Society to Advance Biology Education Research Meeting (SABER) East (2024)
  • "Undergraduate Life Science Professors’ Perception of the Vision and Change Core Content and Competencies for Preparing Students for Science Careers." Society to Advance Biology Education Research Meeting (SABER) East (2024)
  • "Understanding biology students’ undergraduate mentoring experiences at a Hispanic-Serving Institution." Society to Advance Biology Education Research Meeting (SABER) East (2024)
  • "Where do all the Biology majors go?" Society to Advance Biology Education Research Meeting (SABER) East (2024)
  • "Careers in science education (panel member)." Jacobs School of Medicine and Biomedical Sciences (2024)
  • "Careers+, a week-long boot camp for undergraduate career development." Week long career development workshop (2024)
  • "Integrating Culturally Relevant Yucatec Maya Language and Environmental Science Curricula With Maya Communities in Support of Cultural and Science Identity Development." STEM/STEAM and Education Conference (2024)
  • "What is a neuroscientist?" Jacobs School of Medicine and Biomedical Sciences (2024)
  • "Assessing Undergraduate Perspectives on Climate, Culture, and Sense of Belonging in Science Departments." FIU Biosymposium (2024)
  • "Beyond content: integrating scientific skills and career development into undergraduate biology curricula" Florida State University Department of Biology Seminar Series (2024)
  • "Characterizing the landscape of plant science careers" Florida State University Department of Biology Seminar Series (2024)
  • "Cornerstone over Capstone: the case for structured career development opportunities early in the undergraduate Biology curriculum as a way to influence science and Biology identities." University at Buffalo Biological Sciences Seminar Series (2024)
  • "Spring Forward!, a week-long boot camp for undergraduate career development." Florida International University (2024)
  • "Investigating Career and Research Experience Access Through Evidence (iCREATE) at a Hispanic-Serving Institute." Society to Advance Biology Education Research Meeting (SABER) East (2023)
See all (41 more)

Service Activities:

  • Member; Committee to develop the AI-Biomedical Sciences undergraduate major (2025–present)
  • Search Committee, Chair of Pharmacology; Member (2025)
  • Member; Tenurial Committee (2025–present)
  • Journal of College Science Teaching: 2 reviews Journal of Microbiology and Biology Education (JMBE): 3 reviews American Biology Teacher: 1 Course Source: 1 reviews Journal of Biological Education: 1 Heliyon: 1 review Education Sciences: 1; Manuscript Review (2025)
  • L’Oreal Women in Science Award: 8 proposals reviewed International Scientific Committee, Frontiers in Life Sciences, Paris Descartes University, PhD admission proposals: 20 proposals reviewed NSF ISUE for Education Directorate: 8 proposals reviewed; Proposal Review (2025)
  • The National Academies Mirzayan Science & Technology Policy Fellowship: 9 applications reviewed; Review Panels (2025)
  • The National Academies Mirzayan Science & Technology Policy Fellowship: 9 applications reviewed; Review Panels (2024)
  • ; Faculty Senate, member (2024–present)
  • L’Oreal Women in Science Award: 8 proposals reviewed International Scientific Committee, Frontiers in Life Sciences, Paris Descartes University, PhD admission proposals: 20 proposals reviewed NSF MCA for Education Directorate: 7 proposals reviewed; Proposal review (2024)
  • Journal of Microbiology and Biology Education (JMBE): 2 reviews Course Source: 2 reviews PNAS Nexus: 1 review PLOS One: 1 review Learning and Instruction: 1 review Plants, Planet, People: 1 review Discover Education: 1 review Heliyon: 1 review Pharmacology Research & Perspectives: 1 review BioScience: 1 review; Manuscript review (2024)
  • ; Graduate Curriculum Committee (2024–present)
  • member; PPBS Graduate Admissions Committee (2023–present)
  • ; Faculty Council (2023–2025)

School News:

In the Media:


Clinical Specialties:

Clinical Offices:

Insurance Accepted:



Contact Information

955 Main Street
3213
Buffalo, New York 14203
Phone: 716-881-8003
mrm10@buffalo.edu