Step 1 Delay Policy

I. Introduction

It is policy of the University at Buffalo Jacobs School of Medicine and Biomedical Sciences that all Phase 1 students pass the USMLE Step 1 examination in order to progress to Phase 2 of the MD Program [4.2 Promotion from Phase 1 to Phase 2]. The deadline for students to take the USMLE Step 1 exam is determined by the School and displayed on the official Office of Medical Education (OME) calendar. USMLE Step 1 must be passed within 24 months of the completion of all Phase 1 required courses (including leaves of absences) [4.2.2. USMLE Step 1 Timeline]. 

II. Step 1 Delay

Students may request to delay their USMLE Step 1 exam to a later date for academic reasons or personal extenuating circumstances. All Delays require approval by OSAA before the applicable testing deadline. Approval of the Delay is conditional upon compliance with the written requirements established by OSAA.

III. Process for Requesting a Delay

Should a student fail to meet indicators established by the Office of Student and Academic Affairs (OSAA) and the Educational Success Program team as outlined in the course IMC 630: USMLE Step 1 Preparation, the student may request a Delay of the Step 1 testing deadline. [Testing deadline is defined as the deadline set by OSAA for all students of a specific cohort to sit for Step 1.]

a. Short Term Delay

i.  Definition: An approved Short-Term Delay provides up to four (4) additional weeks of dedicated study time for Step 1 preparation. 

ii.  Request: The student initiates a Short-Term Delay request in collaboration with a Learning Specialist. Students may be recommended for a Delay if they are not meeting the benchmarks established by OSAA and the Learning Specialists one week prior to the annual Step 1 deadline. The Learning Specialist will provide the student with a Short-Term Delay Request Form and instructions for completing and submitting the request. 

iii.  Prior to Approval: Upon submission of the Short-Term Delay Request Form, the student must acknowledge and agree to the revised testing deadline and all required meetings, assessments, and preparation activities. Students must fulfill all requirements outlined in the delay plan to maintain eligibility and for consideration of any subsequent delays. The student must also meet with the OSAA Phase 1 Dean to review Step 1 readiness, academic progress, and the potential impact of the Short-Term Delay on the start of Phase 2. 

iv.  Approval: Upon approval, the student will receive an Approved Short-Term Delay Letter of Agreement via email. Students will be granted up to an additional 4 weeks of dedicated study time during which they are required to meet at least weekly with a Learning Specialist and complete their individualized Step 1 preparation plan and required assessments.  

v.  Impacts: A Short-Term Delay will impact the dedicated Health Sciences Scholarly Project (HSSP) block and will require the student to complete all HSSP requirements prior to transitioning to Phase 3. A Short-Term Delay will not impact graduation year pending future performance.

b. Extended Delay

i.  Definition: An approved Extended Delay provides up to 10 additional weeks of dedicated study time for Step 1 preparation. Early return to Phase 2 is not permitted during this period. 

ii.  Request: Should a student require additional time beyond a Short-Term Delay, a Learning Specialist may recommend the student for an Extended Delay. The Learning Specialist will provide the student with the Extended Delay Request Form and instructions for completing and submitting the request. 

iii.  Prior to Approval: Upon submission of the Extended Delay Request Form, the student must acknowledge and agree to the revised testing deadline and all required meetings, assessments, and preparation activities. Students must fulfill all requirements to maintain eligibility and for consideration of a Leave of Absence. The student must also meet with the OSAA Phase 1 Dean to review readiness, academic progress, and the impact of the Extended Delay on the start of Phase 2.  

iv.  Approval: Upon approval, the student will receive an Approved Extended Delay Letter of Agreement via email documenting the revised testing deadline and all associated requirements. Students will be granted up to an additional 10 weeks of dedicated study time during which they are required to meet at least weekly with a Learning Specialist and complete their individualized Step 1 preparation plan and required assessments. 

v.  Impacts: With an approved Extended Delay, OSAA will adjust the student’s Phase 2 schedule accordingly. During the delay period, the student must participate in and complete the Clinical Reasoning and Synthesis course and participate in Phase 2 Orientation. An Extended Delay will also impact the dedicated Health Sciences Scholarly Project (HSSP) block and will require the student to complete all HSSP requirements prior to transitioning to Phase 3. An Extended Delay could impact graduation year pending future performance and will limit flexibility within Phase 3.

Failure to comply with the approved attestation or letter of agreement may result in a review of the student’s academic status by OSAA and a referral to the Professional Conduct Committee. 

IV. Leave of Absence

i.  Definition: Students who do not test after both a short term and extended Delay will be required to take a Leave of Absence (LOA) (JSMBS Academic Status Policies: Section 9. Leave of Absence Policy). No additional extension under the 4-week or 10-week academic Delay process is available beyond that period. The student will rejoin with the next class upon successful passing of USMLE Step 1. 

ii.  Request: Should a student require additional time beyond an Extended Delay, a Learning Specialist may recommend a LOA. The Learning Specialist and/or OSAA will provide the online Leave of Absence (LOA) Request Form to the student.  

iii.  Prior to Approval: Upon submission of the LOA Request Form, the student will meet with the OSAA Phase 1 Dean to review academic progress, financial aid implications and the impact of the LOA on the start of Phase 2. Students on LOA must adhere to the testing deadline established by OSAA and Learning Specialists. 

iv.  Approval: Upon approval, the student will receive an Approved Leave of Absence Letter of Agreement via email documenting the revised testing deadline and all associated requirements.  

v.  Impacts: Students who are placed on an LOA will have their schedules dropped until they have passed USMLE Step 1. Students will not have financial aid during a semester long LOA. Students will not have access to the School building during a semester long LOA.  

vi.  Return from LOA: Students on LOA for Step 1 preparation must continue to meet regularly with a Learning Specialist and comply with the individualized preparation expectations established by OSAA. Students who return from LOA after passing USMLE Step 1 will have new clerkship schedules based on availability as determined by OSAA and the Phase 2 Dean.  

vii.  Failure to Comply: Students who do not take USMLE Step 1 within the established timeframe will be referred to the Student Progress Committee for review and deliberation, which may include actions up to and including dismissal.

V. Additional Considerations

a. Personal Extenuating Circumstances

In the event of an extenuating personal circumstance, a student must meet with a Student Affairs Dean to request a Delay. The testing deadline will be determined by OSAA based on the student’s specific circumstances and communicated in writing, along with any associated expectations or requirements. 

b. Phase 1 Course Remediation

A student who is required to remediate one or more third semester Phase 1 courses must do so prior to taking USMLE Step 1. The student must meet with OSAA and a Learning Specialist to determine the timing of Step 1 and start of clinical rotations.

VI. Failure of Step 1 Exam

In the event of a Step 1 failure, the student must meet with OSAA and a Learning Specialist to develop an individualized remediation plan. The plan, including the reexamination date and required preparation activities, must be approved by OSAA and a Learning Specialist. The student is expected to complete the requirements of the approved plan. A student must achieve a passing score to start Phase 2.

VII. Summary

Delay of USMLE Step 1 may affect and delay the timeline of both residency application and graduation. Approval of a Delay does not guarantee preservation of the original Phase 2 schedule or anticipated graduation date. An unapproved delay in taking Step 1 will be noted in the MSPE as a professionalism concern. Students should not consider delaying the start of the Health Sciences System Scholarly project or clinical rotations as a potential benefit or personal option. Delaying the start of their project or clerkships will decrease the flexibility and benefits of the Well Beyond curriculum.